You’re going to need to try this Creme Brulee French Toast as soon as you can. It’s decadent and rich and perfect to impress whoever you’re looking to impress. Maybe it’s just for yourself, but I’m totally not judging.
It’s so easy to make. Just remember you’re going to need to soak the bread overnight to ensure that every bit of bread is soaking in the custard. In the morning, you’ll bake it in a brown sugar and butter mixture that gives it that awesome crust on top. Heart eye emojis everywhere.
It’s super rich and sweet, but definitely delicious and easy to throw together. One batch will make enough for 8-10 people depending on the size of the bread and how hungry everyone is. I went with a small french loaf and ended up with 20 slices. They all fit on my biggest baking sheet so that’s something you’ll have to consider if you pick a bigger loaf. You might have to halve the custard to each sheet and adjust the baking time a little.
Then again.. if there’s extras you could always heat it up and scoop some vanilla ice cream onto it for dessert. I may or may not be telling you this out of past experience..
Mix some berries with some sugar to macerate them a little to serve on top of the toast. Then top it with some powdered sugar because there is no way there’s enough calories in it yet and you always need powdered sugar on french toast.
Prepare for the sugar high and enjoy!
Adapted from the New York Times.
Sunday 28th of November 2021
Very yummy. My daughter and husband said it was the best French toast they ever had and insisted I keep this recipe. We are all foodies in this household so that means something! I made a couple alterations due to lack of ingredients and comments from other reviews of too sweet or soggy that I read. I didn’t have any orange juice, I only had 3 eggs but was only serving 3 people, and I had only found this recipe an hour before I needed to serve it so letting it sit in the refrigerator overnight was not an option. I don’t write reviews on recipes because most people have usually said it all. But this is a special recipe and deserves recognition. It’s easy to improve on a good thing but much more difficult to create a good thing. My hat is off to Sam, the creator of this recipe, which is now a keeper in this family and will be made again and again. No slaving over a hot stove cooking in batches-they are all done perfectly and ready to serve at the same time. Delightfully crispy sweet on the outside and moist & custardy fluffy on the inside. Yum! These are the alterations I made: I sliced seven 3/4 inch slices of 4 day old Costco’s County Bread, used only 1 cup half and half, 3 eggs, pinch of nutmeg, I added 1/4 teaspoon almond extract with the vanilla. I let the the bread soak for about 30 minutes till it soaked up the whole mixture turning the slices over occasionally on my kitchen counter. For the butter mixture I only used 2-3Tablespoons brown sugar and 6 Tablespoons butter with 2-3 drops of Orange oil. I preheated my oven to 375degrees F. and placed the oven rack on the lower third of the oven. For my oven it is the second shelf from the bottom. I placed the slices on top the butter mixer of a lipped cookie sheet (baking pan) lined with Reynolds non-stick foil and baked per directions for 20 minutes turning over and baking for 5 minutes more. It couldn’t be more simple or more delicious. I served it with butter and maple syrup but can be served as is— it’s that good. The easy prep, easy cooking, easy clean up, with outstanding results earns all the stars I am able to give. This recipe should be in every Cooks recipe box.
Friday 30th of September 2022
Darlene I think you made my entire year with this comment! I am SO happy to hear that you and your family love this recipe and want to make it again. It's really special to know that something I worked on gets incorporated into your life! Thank you for the kind words!
Saturday 13th of November 2021
This was soooo good!! I only had 2 eggs and no half and half , replaced nutmeg with cinnamon and these creme brulee french toast still came out really well . My entire family gave it 2 thumbs up. My 8yr old daughter wants it everyday 🙂 Thank you for this fantastic recipe!
Monday 15th of November 2021
So glad to hear that you and your family enjoyed, Sandrine!
Monday 16th of November 2020
Can you sub texas toast slices for French bread with this recipe?
Monday 16th of November 2020
Great question! I haven't tried it so I can't say for certain, but I feel like it'd be a great substitute and would hold up well!
Sunday 26th of May 2019
Can this be frozen to use at a later date?
Tuesday 4th of June 2019
Great question, Steff! I haven't frozen it myself to try, but definitely feel free to reach back out to see if you have luck with that! I'd love to know as well.
Thursday 14th of February 2019
Need the nutrition info please.